Lip Pencil
Product Details
Web ID: 11202643I'm glad it's back.
I'm glad they brought this color back from retirement. This is a nice nude lip liner for dark tan to deep skin. It looks great with my medium brown lipsticks. My only concern is that it a bit drying, but it does stay on.
Pretty Lip Pencil
OMG! I love this color. I have been praying for currant liner to return to MAC, but this color is the next best or better. The pencil is smaller than the other MAC lip pencils, but the color chemistry compensates. I love it!
Recommends this product
Customer review from maccosmetics.com
So great to have Hodgepodge again!
I am a fair skinned blonde and Hodgepodge is one of the few colors that works for my skin tone, and I'm so happy to be able to order it again! I'm hoping that MAC will bring it back as a regular full sized option. In the meantime, I'm just happy to be able to use it again.
Recommends this product
Customer review from maccosmetics.com
Lip liners
OMG Soooooooooo very disappointed in the size difference, If you're going to lessen the pencil then lessen the price. Not meaning to sound cheap but who wants to pay more for less. Color is on point.
Customer review from maccosmetics.com
Response from maccosmetics.com
Thank you for your feedback, Tammy! We want you to be completely satisfied with your maccosmetics.com purchases. You'll be pleased to know Nightmoth Lip Pencil is part of our permanent collection and available in our classic black packaging here: http://bit.ly/MACLipPencils__. Please reach our Order Team at 1.800.588.0070 or via Live Chat here: http://bit.ly/MACChat and we'll gladly assist with a return/exchange.
Great colors!
Chestnut is a staple brown for every girl, and Hodgepodge is a close second. Both are great if you're going for nude lip. Pair with the lip gloss/lip stick for the perfect combo.
Beautiful Color but Size Challenged
Received my MAC order only to find that the pencils were significantly smaller than the traditional pencil. At least the colors were spot on and were real wood. Synthetic pencils are horrible for sharpening. This product has no Value what so ever, and is a cheap attempt by MAC to receive more for less. Not a good thing especially since wearing liner and lipstick has gone way down during this Pandemic.
Customer review from maccosmetics.com
Response from maccosmetics.com
Thank you for sharing this valuable feedback with us; Know that your thoughts will be shared internally with our team. If you wish to return or exchange your Lip Pencil, please phone our Order Team at 1-800-588-0070 for direct assistance.
It's tiny!
I feel like this is a sample size. The color is great.. but the size not so much. Never knew that .01 difference would of been so noticeable but it is. Save your money for a regular strip down or cork pencil.
Customer review from maccosmetics.com
Love the return of Hodgepodge - size...not so much
I was so happy to see the return of Hodgepodge that I bought two. However, I wasn't expecting a shortened pencil. This is 0.04 oz/1.14g vs. 0.05 oz/1.45gn(size of a pencil from the permanent collection). If I didn't love lip liners so much this wouldn't matter to me but since I always use a liner with my glosses/lipsticks, I will burn through this quickly. Again, I'm happy to see the return of this shade and I do love "I Gotta Man" lipstick and "But Ain't Got No Manners" lipglass but the size of this pencil is disappointing. I included a size comparison to an unused backup lip pencil I had in my stash.
Customer review from maccosmetics.com