Karen ScottTurtleneck Sweater, Created for Macy's

Thinner than Thin

This turtleneck top is very thin. I don't know why it's called a "sweater". The fabric is very nice, and does NOT pill at all, even after multiple washes; however, they should have made this thicker. The lighter color is super see-through, so unless you want people seeing your bra you would have to wear another top underneath it. I only kept the black color because it was not see-through, but it's so darn thin I have to wear another cardigan over it all the top to keep from getting cold. The strange thing is, that if the weather is cold enough that you want to reach for a turtleneck in your closet, this would not be sufficient. It's more like a thin tee shirt with a literally a "turtle neck", so I would call this a turtleneck TEE shirt.

Wish I'd bought more!

I absolutely love this sweater and wish I'd bought them in all colors before they sold out in my size. The fabric has the perfect amount of give, while still holding its shape (when I take it off it doesn't look stretched out). It is comfortable and classy - feels like a much more expensive garment than it cost. Great buy!

A KEEPER

Nice fit. Nice fabric. I'd buy again in additional colors. I'm 5'3, 135 pounds. I sometimes take a medium. But in Karen Scott, I wear a small. Bought the charcoal heather and merlot. Colors are accurate.

Was way small for the size I ordered

I would pass this one up.

Too clingy and not flattering at all. I returned it.

Just what I was looking for!

I purchased this in black and went down a size from small to x-small and it fits great. I'm so glad that I got this sweater since it is light weight and the cut is exactly what I wanted. I'll pair this with a pair of pearls from Macys for a classic look.

Beautiful Turtleneck Sweater

I would give this review 5stars except it had a snag left shoulder. I pushed it back through, but this material will snag easily. Be very careful with your jewelry, especially rings, or bumping against anything, it will snag easily and quickly. It's a very delicate and very soft material. I love the burgundy color. Size fits. I'm 5'4" weigh 170 and the large fits perfectly.

Nice turtle neck

I ordered one and when I received it I liked it so much I ordered two more I'm a size 40 bust and I ordered the medium and it fits perfectly not too tight not too loose comes to below the hips but you're able to ruffle it up a little. it's is not short. I love it and I will buy more once they go on sale